Write down every project idea you have for the quarter. Score each one from 1 to 5 on impact, confidence and effort, add the three scores and divide by three. Your top three become your projects, as long as at least one of them helps the stage that's holding your business back. Everything else goes on your later list.
By the time you get to planning a new quarter, you usually have more ideas than time. A podcast, a new offer, a website redesign, better welcome emails, running ads. They all sound good, and it's hard to tell which ones are worth doing first.
The Creator's MBA Playbook uses a simple scoring method called ICE to sort them out. It takes about twenty minutes, and it's the step that turns your list of ideas into your projects for the quarter. It comes right after you've looked back at 2026 and found the stage that's holding your business back in the 2027 planning process.
Start with every idea.
Before you score anything, write down every project you're thinking about for the quarter. Pull from a few places:
- Your year-end wrap-up, especially the lessons about your audience and your offers
- The stage you found that's holding your business back, and anything that would help it
- Your later list from last quarter, if you have one
- Anything you keep telling yourself you should get to
Don't judge them yet. The scoring will do that for you.
The three scores
Give each idea a score from 1 to 5 on each of these:
Impact
How big a result could this create if it works? A 1 barely moves anything. A 5 would make a real difference in your sales, your list or how many customers stay.
Confidence
How sure are you that you can do this well? A 1 is something you've never tried and aren't sure how to do. A 5 is something you've done before with good results.
Effort
How much time and energy will it take? This one works backwards. A project that takes a few hours gets a 5, and one that takes most of the quarter gets a 1.
Add the three scores together and divide by three. That's the ICE score for that idea.
An example with seven ideas.
Here's what this looks like for a made-up business with a $997 course and a $97 a month membership. The owner's bottleneck is Engage, because a lot of people join the list but very few buy the course.
| Project idea | Impact | Confidence | Effort | ICE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Automatic testimonial request a few weeks after someone buys the course | 3 | 5 | 5 | 4.3 |
| Welcome series for new members of the membership | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4.0 |
| Add a free workshop invitation to the welcome emails that leads into the course | 4 | 4 | 3 | 3.7 |
| Add an annual plan to the membership | 4 | 3 | 4 | 3.7 |
| Run ads to the freebie | 4 | 2 | 2 | 2.7 |
| Start a weekly podcast | 3 | 3 | 1 | 2.3 |
| Redesign the whole website | 2 | 3 | 1 | 2.0 |
The testimonial request and the membership welcome series are the top two. Then there's a tie at 3.7 between the workshop invitation and the annual plan.
The tie gets broken by the bottleneck. The workshop invitation helps Engage, the stage where this business is losing the most people, and the membership already has a project in the top three. So the workshop invitation makes the cut, and the annual plan goes on the later list for next quarter.
The podcast and the website redesign both scored low mostly because of effort. That doesn't mean they're bad ideas. It means they'd take up most of the quarter, and the other projects will do more with the same time right now.
Be honest when you score
It's tempting to give your favorite ideas 5s across the board. Most good ideas land at a 3 or a 4, and that's normal.
A 5 on all three would mean a big result that you know you can pull off and that barely takes any time. Very few ideas really fit that. If you find yourself scoring something that high, ask yourself whether it really fits all three.
"Most good ideas land at a 3 or a 4, and that's normal."
Dr. Destini CoppPick your top three
Your three highest scores become your projects for the quarter. Before you turn them into goals, check two things.
Does at least one help your bottleneck?
If none of your top three help the stage that's holding your business back, look again. You might need to move a lower-scoring idea up, or come up with a new idea that goes straight at that stage. It's your call, but make it on purpose.
Do they fit your hours?
Add up roughly how many hours each project will take and compare that to the time you have this quarter after your newsletter, customer emails and the regular work of running your business. If it doesn't fit, swap a big project for a smaller one or plan to start one of them later in the quarter.
When your confidence is low
Some ideas score high on impact and low on confidence. In the example, running ads to the freebie could make a big difference, but the owner has never run ads before.
When that happens, you don't have to choose between doing the whole thing or skipping it. Run a small test first. Spend a small amount on ads for two weeks at the start of the quarter and watch what happens. If it goes well, the confidence score goes up and it may make your list next quarter.
Your list might be short, and that's fine. Score what you have the same way. When you don't have an offer or a list yet, the ideas that get either one live usually score highest on impact, so they'll rise to the top on their own.
What happens to the rest
Every idea that didn't make your top three goes on your later list with its score next to it. Next quarter, you'll score them again. Some will move up because your business changed, and some will drop because they don't matter as much anymore.
Once you have your three projects, the next step is turning each one into a goal with a due date and a number to track.
The ICE scoring page and your later list are both in the 2027 Creator's MBA Playbook.
The 2027 planning series.
This post is part of a series that walks through the whole 2027 planning process, one step per post:
- How to Plan 2027 for Your Digital Product Business (the overview)
- How to Do a Year-End Wrap-Up Before You Plan 2027
- How to Find the One Stage Holding Your Business Back
- How to Decide Which Projects Are Worth Your Time · you're reading this one
- Why You Should Only Set Three Goals Each Quarter
- How to Turn One Goal Into a 90-Day Plan You'll Follow
- 3 Systems to Keep Running in Your Busiest Month
- The 10-Minute Monthly Check-In for Your Business
- How to Use Claude to Plan Your 2027 Quarters
Score your ideas and plan 2027 in one place
The Playbook has the ICE scoring page from this post ready to fill in, along with every other step for planning 2027, from your year-end look-back to your 12-week plan. When you get it from my website, you also get the AI companion that walks you through your plan in Claude and the live planning workshop.
Get the Playbook for $97 →Frequently asked.
How do I prioritize projects in my business?
Score each idea from 1 to 5 on impact, confidence and effort, add the three scores and divide by three. Your top three scores become your projects for the quarter, as long as at least one of them helps the stage of your business that's holding you back.
What is the ICE scoring method?
ICE stands for impact, confidence and effort. You score each project idea from 1 to 5 on all three, with lower effort getting a higher score, and then average the three numbers to compare your ideas side by side.
What should I do when two projects have the same score?
Pick the one that helps your bottleneck, the stage of your business where the most people drop off. If that doesn't settle it, pick the one that takes less time.
What if I'm not confident I can pull off a project?
Run a small test first. Put the test in the first two weeks of your quarter, and only build the full project if the test goes well.
Why do most of my ideas score a 3 or a 4?
That's normal. A 5 on all three would mean a big result that you know you can pull off and that barely takes any time, and very few ideas really fit that.
Dr. Destini Copp helps digital product creators build sustainable, systems-based businesses through the Creator Growth Flywheel framework. She's the founder of Creator's MBA and HobbyScool, and has been teaching online business strategy for over a decade. Learn more →

