Rate the five stages of your business from 1 to 5, with one line about what's working and one about what needs work. Look for the biggest drop between one stage and the next, and then look one stage before it, because that's often where the problem starts. Pick that stage plus one stage that's already working, and build your first quarter goals around those two.
When sales slow down, the first thing a lot of creators reach for is more traffic. They start a new freebie, post more on social media or run ads to get more people on the list.
Sometimes that's the right call. But if new people are already signing up and then not buying, or buying once and never coming back, more traffic won't change much. You'll just have more people running into the same problem.
That's why the second step in the 2027 planning process is rating the five stages of your business. It shows you where people are dropping off, so you can put your time into the stage that will actually move your numbers in 2027.
The five stages of your business.
I use a framework called the Creator Growth Flywheel. It's the five stages a customer moves through in a digital product business, from the day they find you to the day they tell a friend about you.
Attract
New people find you and join your email list. This is your freebie, your opt-in page, collaborations and anything that helps people discover you.
Engage
New subscribers get to know you and make a first purchase. This is your welcome emails, a lower-priced first offer and your sales pages.
Nurture
You keep showing up with helpful content every week. For most creators this is a weekly newsletter, plus a podcast, blog or videos.
Retain
Customers stay with you, buy again or keep their membership. This is your onboarding, your check-ins and your upgrade offers.
Advocate
Happy customers tell other people about you. This is testimonials, referrals and affiliates.
The last stage connects back to the first one. When happy customers send you new people, those people show up in Attract, and the whole thing starts again with less effort from you.
How to rate each stage
Give each stage a score from 1 to 5. Here's a simple way to think about the scores:
- 1: you don't have anything set up for this stage yet.
- 3: you have something in place, but it's not consistent or you're not sure it's working.
- 5: it runs every week and your numbers show it's working.
Compare each stage against your own numbers from earlier in the year, and leave other people's numbers out of it. A 40% open rate might be great for one list and a drop for another. What matters is whether your own numbers are going up, staying the same or going down.
Next to each score, write one line about what's working and one line about what needs work. Keep it short and specific. "My welcome emails never mention my program" is much more useful than "Engage needs work."
How to find your bottleneck.
Your bottleneck is the stage where the most people drop off. Here's how to find it.
Look for the biggest drop
Look at your scores and your numbers side by side and find the spot where things fall off the most from one stage to the next. Maybe you have a strong list and a great newsletter, but almost no one buys. Or maybe people buy, but very few ever buy a second time.
Be careful comparing percentages between stages. The percentage of people who buy will always be smaller than the percentage who open your emails, so that comparison will always make the buying stages look worst. Compare each stage to its own earlier numbers and to your goal instead.
Look one stage back
The stage right before the biggest drop is often where the problem actually starts. If new subscribers rarely buy, check whether your freebie and your first paid offer go together before you rewrite the offer. If buyers rarely come back, check whether your weekly content ever points them to a next step before you change your membership.
Don't blame Attract by default
Only call Attract your bottleneck when new people really aren't finding you, or when the people who sign up aren't the right fit for what you sell.
"If people are signing up and then leaving further down the line, more traffic won't fix it."
Dr. Destini CoppCheck whether the last stage feeds the first
Ask yourself whether happy customers are sending you new people. If they aren't, every new customer has to come from your own marketing. When the rest of your business is doing fine, this is often the bottleneck, and fixing it makes every other stage a little easier.
Three examples
Here's what this looks like with a few made-up businesses.
The course creator with a big list
Say you have a growing list and a $997 course, but very few subscribers ever buy it. The biggest drop is between Attract and Engage. When you look one stage back, you notice your freebie is about social media and your course is about email marketing. People are signing up for something that doesn't lead to what you sell. Your bottleneck is Engage, and your first fix might be a new freebie that leads straight into the course.
The membership that loses people in month two
Say you run a $97 a month membership. New members join every month, but a lot of them cancel after the second payment. The biggest drop is in Retain. When you look at what happens in a new member's first week, you see they get a login email and nothing else. Your first fix might be a short welcome series that helps new members get one result in their first two weeks.
The program with happy customers and no referrals
Say you run a $997 program and your customers love it, but you've never asked for a testimonial and you don't have an affiliate program. Your list only grows when you work on it yourself. Your bottleneck is Advocate, and your first fix might be a testimonial request that goes out automatically a few weeks after someone buys.
Pick a second stage too
The Playbook asks which two stages, if you made them better, would make the biggest difference to your business. One is your bottleneck. The other is a stage where the work you put in keeps paying off later.
That second stage is usually one of these:
- A stage that's already working. A strong weekly newsletter can carry a new offer or a testimonial request to people who already trust you.
- A system that runs without you. A welcome series, an automatic testimonial request or an affiliate program keeps working every day once it's built.
Sometimes your bottleneck and your second stage are the same stage. That's fine. Write down why you picked each one, because you'll use both when you set your goals.
Rate each stage based on what you know, and pick the stage with the lowest score as your bottleneck. Then start tracking one number for that stage, like how many new subscribers you get each week or how many buy in their first month. Next quarter you'll be able to rate it with real numbers.
What to do next
Once you know your two stages, the next step is to score your project ideas and pick up to three goals for the first quarter of 2027. At least one of those goals should go straight at your bottleneck.
You'll rate the five stages again at the start of every quarter. As you fix one stage, a different one usually becomes the bottleneck, and that's how you know your plan is working.
The rating page, with space for your scores and your notes on each stage, is in the 2027 Creator's MBA Playbook.
The 2027 planning series.
This post is part of a series that walks through the whole 2027 planning process, one step per post:
- How to Plan 2027 for Your Digital Product Business (the overview)
- How to Do a Year-End Wrap-Up Before You Plan 2027
- How to Find the One Stage Holding Your Business Back · you're reading this one
- How to Decide Which Projects Are Worth Your Time
- Why You Should Only Set Three Goals Each Quarter
- How to Turn One Goal Into a 90-Day Plan You'll Follow
- 3 Systems to Keep Running in Your Busiest Month
- The 10-Minute Monthly Check-In for Your Business
- How to Use Claude to Plan Your 2027 Quarters
Rate your business and plan 2027 in one place
The Playbook has the rating page from this post ready to fill in, plus every step that comes after it, from scoring your ideas to your 12-week plan. When you get it from my website, you also get the AI companion that walks you through your plan in Claude and the live planning workshop.
Get the Playbook for $97 →Frequently asked.
How do I figure out what's holding my business back?
Rate the five stages of your business from 1 to 5: Attract, Engage, Nurture, Retain and Advocate. Then look for the biggest drop between one stage and the next. That's usually your bottleneck, and it's where your first goal for the quarter should go.
What is a bottleneck in a digital product business?
It's the stage where the most people drop off on the way from finding you to buying from you again and telling their friends. Fixing it usually helps every stage after it.
Should I just focus on getting more traffic?
Only if new people aren't finding you or the wrong people are signing up. If people are joining your list and then not buying, or buying once and leaving, more traffic won't help much.
How do I rate my business if I don't have many numbers yet?
Rate each stage based on what you know, and pick the lowest score as your bottleneck. Then start tracking one number for that stage so you can rate it with real numbers next quarter.
How often should I rate the five stages of my business?
Once a quarter, as part of planning the next 90 days. Your bottleneck will change as you fix things, so rating every quarter keeps your goals pointed at the right stage.
Dr. Destini Copp helps digital product creators build sustainable, systems-based businesses through the Creator Growth Flywheel framework. She's the founder of Creator's MBA and HobbyScool, and has been teaching online business strategy for over a decade. Learn more →

