254: Why Your Newsletter Isn’t Making Money (And How to Fix It)
If you’ve been sending consistent, thoughtful emails but the results still feel underwhelming, there’s a reason and it’s not that newsletters stopped working. It’s that the rules have quietly changed.
In this episode, I dig into the State of Newsletters 2026 report from Beehiive and share why email is now the most stable (and profitable) part of the creator economy. I’ll walk you through what’s shifting, what’s no longer working, and how to build a newsletter system that actually supports your business long-term.
What You’ll Learn:
Why newsletters feel broken—and why they’re not
The new role email plays in your business
How to shift from megaphone to “digital coffee shop”
The #1 reason newsletters don’t drive revenue
Why 90-day planning changes everything
If your newsletter has been running on guesswork, this episode will help you bring structure, strategy, and results back into your inbox.
Mentioned in this episode:
Why Your Newsletter Isn’t Working
If you've been sending thoughtful, consistent emails but still aren't seeing results, it's not because newsletters stopped working. It’s because the rules have changed. And in 2026, understanding this shift could be the difference between an email list that quietly converts—and one that stays stuck.
I recently read Beehiiv’s State of Newsletters 2026 report, and it confirmed what I’ve been seeing across the digital business world. Email is no longer just a marketing channel. It’s a business model. In this post, I’m breaking down what’s changed, why email is now the most stable place to build your brand, and how to rethink your newsletter as a system that supports long-term revenue.
Email Is Now the Operating System of Your Business
According to the Beehiiv report, newsletters have evolved into what they call multi-channel media hubs anchored in the inbox. That language matters.
We’re no longer just sending emails to drive traffic. We’re building spaces where content, offers, community, and conversations converge. This shift—from megaphones to ecosystems—is one of the most important changes digital business owners need to understand right now.
Your inbox is no longer a side channel. It’s the central hub where your products are sold, your relationships are nurtured, and your brand lives.
From Megaphones to Digital Coffee Shops
For years, we treated newsletters like digital billboards: broadcast a message and hope someone responds. But in 2026, the more effective model looks a lot more like building a digital coffee shop.
In this model:
Your newsletter is the shop: a space you own and control.
Your content is the coffee: high-quality, intentional, and human.
Your community is the heartbeat: engagement, not just audience.
Your offers are the premium experiences: for your most loyal readers.
AI becomes the barista machine: automating the repetitive tasks so you can focus on what only you can do—thinking, connecting, and leading.
This is the kind of system that invites people to stay, participate, and buy—not just consume and scroll past.
Why Most Newsletters Stall (Even When You’re Doing Everything “Right”)
Here’s the hard truth: most newsletters aren’t failing because of poor writing or inconsistency. They’re failing because they lack intention and structure.
Too many creators plan emails around content and inspiration, but not revenue. And without a system that connects your messaging to your business model, results stay inconsistent. I’ve been there—sending emails week after week with occasional sales, but no predictability.
What changed for me was moving from weekly guesswork to quarterly planning. Instead of asking, “What do I send this week?” I started asking, “What role does this email play in my system?” That small shift gave me clarity, confidence, and results I could actually build on.
Planning + Structure = Predictable Results
When I studied high-performing newsletters, I saw one clear pattern: they were planned, not pieced together on the fly.
Planning 90 days at a time allows you to map your emails to your offers. You know which emails are for nurturing, which are for selling, and which are for setting up your next big move. It removes the decision fatigue that makes newsletters feel heavy—and brings your entire strategy into alignment.
The Beehiiv report backs this up:
Niche creators saw a 138% increase in paid subscriptions last year.
The median time to earn the first dollar dropped to 66 days.
Open rates have risen to 41%.
People are reading. They are buying. But they’re responding to intention, not random content blasts.
3 Shifts to Make Your Newsletter Work in 2026
If you want your newsletter to start pulling its weight in your business, start here:
Niche down and own your space.
Generalist newsletters are struggling. Specificity builds trust, engagement, and revenue.Automate with care.
Use automation to reduce friction—welcome sequences, re-engagement flows—but keep your voice personal. AI should support you, not replace you.Think community, not just audience.
A smaller, engaged group will always outperform a massive passive list. Focus on participation and relationships, not just numbers.
Ready to Make It Intentional?
Inside the Newsletter Profit Club, I walk you through how to build a repeatable, revenue-supporting system for your newsletter. From creating a 90-day plan to layering in monetization, automation, and growth strategies—it’s all about helping your email strategy support your business without burning you out.
Because here’s the truth: email isn’t going anywhere. But how we use it is changing. And with the right structure in place, your newsletter can become the most valuable asset in your digital business.
Pin this and save for later
Transcript
[00:00:00] Welcome to the Creator's MBA podcast, your go-to resource for mastering the art and science of digital product entrepreneurship. My name is Dr. Destini Copp, and I help business owners generate consistent revenue from their digital product business without the need to be glued to their desk, constantly live launching, or worrying about the social media algorithms.
I hope you enjoy our episode today.
[00:00:40] Hi there, Destini here, and welcome back to the Creator's MBA podcast. I'm super excited that you're spending this time with me. Lately, I've been thinking about why newsletters feel so frustrating for so many smart, capable online business owners. And I'm not talking about beginners—I mean people who are doing the work, sending out emails consistently, and still not seeing the kind of results that make the effort feel justified.
[00:01:12] Here's the part that matters: the problem isn't that newsletters stopped working—it's that the rules have changed over time. And at the same time, I've been paying very close attention to what's happening in the broader newsletter ecosystem. Especially after reading the State of Newsletters 2026 report that just came out this week from Beehiiv.
[00:01:39] What struck me is how deeply connected those two things are. On one hand, the data shows that newsletters are healthier than ever—revenue is up, engagement is up, and monetization is happening faster. But on the other hand, a lot of individual creators are still struggling to make newsletters work in a way that feels predictable and intentional.
[00:02:08] So today, I want to bridge that gap. I want to talk about what's actually changing in the newsletter landscape, why email is quietly becoming the most stable center of the creator economy, and how misunderstanding this shift is exactly why so many newsletters still aren't making money—even when that business owner is doing almost everything "right."
[00:02:36] Let's talk about the big picture and what the data actually says. The State of Newsletters 2026 report from Beehiiv made something very clear: email is no longer just a marketing channel. For solopreneurs, creators, service providers, and coaches, it is a business model in its own right.
[00:02:59] While social media platforms spent the last year dealing with algorithm changes and AI-curated feeds, newsletters quietly became the most stable place to build an audience you actually own. The report describes newsletters evolving from simple email updates into what it calls "multi-channel media hubs anchored in the inbox."
[00:03:27] I love that—multi-channel media hubs that are anchored in the inbox. That language matters because it tells us that the inbox is no longer just a traffic source. It’s the operating system of your business. It's where your content lives, it's where your products are sold, it's where communities form, and it's where your podcast, your events, and your experiences all connect back to one central place.
[00:03:57] Even independent creators are no longer operating with a single weekly email. They're building ecosystems, and the inbox is the anchor. This shift is driven largely by ownership. After watching reach disappear overnight on social media platforms, business owners started to prioritize permission-based relationships. And email is predictable in a way that social media simply isn’t.
[00:04:29] The Beehiiv report also highlights a move toward consolidation. Business owners are simplifying their tech stacks and doing more from one core system instead of spreading energy across disconnected tools and platforms. All of this sets the stage for what comes next.
[00:04:52] For a long time, newsletters were treated like digital megaphones. You stood on a box, shouted out your message, and hoped someone was listening. But I think the 2026 model looks more like building a digital coffee shop.
[00:05:10] In this model, the newsletter is the shop itself. It's the space you own and control—not a social media feed that can change overnight. The content is like the coffee: it needs to be high-quality, intentional, and human enough that people actually want to come back.
[00:05:30] Think Starbucks. They have really good coffee—I want to come back because I love the coffee. The community is the point. Your newsletter is no longer a one-way publishing platform. It’s hospitality. It’s interaction. It’s treating readers like participants, not passive email subscribers.
[00:05:53] Your products and services are the premium offerings—the merchandise and experience your most loyal readers are happy to invest in. AI plays a role here too. I equate it to the barista machine. It automates the repeat work so you can focus on what only you can do: thinking, connecting, leading.
[00:06:19] All of this lines up with what the Beehiiv report emphasized—moving away from one-way publishing toward engagement, community, and participation. Here's a quote from Michael Kaufman that captures it beautifully: "There is a difference between service and hospitality. There's a difference between doing something and doing something because you care."
[00:06:50] That distinction explains a lot of what we’re seeing right now. Most newsletters aren’t failing because of bad writing or inconsistency. They’re stalling because they’re still being run like megaphones in a world that now rewards coffee shops.
[00:07:12] Here's what that looks like: you send thoughtful emails, you share valuable ideas—but selling feels awkward. Promotions feel disruptive. You can't always answer what your newsletter is supposed to do this month. Because most creators plan newsletters around content. Very few plan around revenue.
[00:07:39] That doesn’t mean you don’t have offers—it means they’re not intentionally mapped into your newsletter in a way that makes sense over time. The result? Inconsistent performance. Confidence fades. I’ve been there myself.
[00:08:00] For years, I followed the standard advice. I sent helpful, well-written weekly newsletters. Sometimes things sold—and I thought I was on the right track. But nothing was predictable. Nothing I could plan around or repeat intentionally. That disconnect bothered me.
[00:08:23] When I started studying newsletters that consistently made money across industries, the difference wasn’t clever copy. It was planning. Those creators weren’t deciding what to send one email at a time. They were planning their next quarter—and how it tied to revenue.
[00:08:47] That shift changed everything. When you stop planning one email at a time and start planning with intention—quarter by quarter—the question changes. You stop asking, “What should I send this week?” and start asking, “What role does this email play in the bigger system?”
[00:09:10] Some emails build trust. Others sell. Some prepare your audience for what’s next. The problem isn’t that any of this is wrong—it’s that you don’t know which is which. A 90-day plan gives your newsletter context, confidence, and removes the weekly decision fatigue.
[00:09:35] And the data backs this up. The Beehiiv report showed that niche creators drove a 138% jump in paid subscription revenue last year. The median time to earning the first dollar dropped to 66 days. And open rates increased to 41%. People are reading—and buying.
[00:09:59] But they’re responding to intention, not just noise.
[00:10:05] So what do you do with all of this?
First, niche expertise wins. Generalist newsletters are struggling. Identity- and passion-driven niches are seeing higher engagement and stronger revenue.
[00:10:20] Second, automation is leverage—not a shortcut. Most newsletters still use almost no automation. Automating your welcome flows and re-engagement sequences frees up time. AI should support your voice, not replace it.
[00:10:39] Third, community beats audience. A smaller group of engaged readers outperforms a massive passive list. Treat your newsletter like a system, not a random collection of emails.
[00:10:53] That’s why I created the Newsletter Profit Club. Everything inside is designed to help you build a repeatable newsletter system—one that supports revenue without burning out your audience or yourself.
[00:11:10] Our first members-only workshop focuses on building a clear 90-day newsletter plan. Not just content ideas—but a strategy that connects what you send to how you make money. Then we layer in natural-feeling monetization, automation that keeps your voice, and growth strategies that attract buyers—not just subscribers.
[00:11:36] We also cover decision frameworks so you always know what to send and what to skip.
[00:11:45] If you’ve been sending your newsletter consistently but want it to feel more intentional—this is the work that fixes it.
[00:11:54] Email isn’t going away—it’s evolving. And when newsletters don’t make money, it’s rarely because the business owner isn’t trying hard enough. It’s almost always because the newsletter was never designed as a system in the first place.
[00:12:13] Structure is learnable. Planning is powerful. And the inbox is still one of the most stable places to build a business in 2026.
[00:12:27] Thanks for listening. I’ll include the links to the Beehiiv report and details about the Newsletter Profit Club in the show notes. Bye for now.
[00:12:38] Thanks for listening all the way to the end. If you love the show, I’d appreciate a review on Apple Podcasts or your favorite podcast platform. Have a great day, and bye for now.